Ending Soon! Save 33% on All Access

The Case That Could Change the EB-5 Immigrant Investor Program The lawsuit that could bring back the $500,000 capital investment for the EB-5 program.

By Shai Zamanian Edited by Bill Schulz

Opinions expressed by Entrepreneur contributors are their own.

The EB-5 immigrant investor industry has been on edge for the past two months closely following a case that could drastically change the investor program. The Behring Regional Center v. Wolf, Case No. 3:20-cv-09263 (N.D. Cal) is a lawsuit by Behring Regional Center against the Department of Homeland Security requesting the U.S. District Court of North California to disallow the implementation of the EB-5 modernization rule of 2019. In the lawsuit, Behring claims that the processes used for the implementation of the EB-5 modernization rule of November 2019, which has had grave adverse effects on the program, was done so beyond the scope of power of the then acting Department of Homeland Security officials. Therefore, a clear violation of Administrative Procedures Act as the acting officials had no legal authority to enact this rule.

The EB-5 modernization rule updated various regulations governing the EB-5 immigrant investor program and in doing so subsequently affected the number of investors filing for EB-5 petitions. The main change in the rule was to increase the required capital investment amount from $500,000 to $900,000. Various industry leaders have voiced several concerns that the drastic increase of the investment amount has made the program unattainable for the middle class who have proved to be the main applicants under this program. These middle class families use their entire life savings, retirement annuities and other means to obtain the required investment required for participation in the program. While the program was already perceived as a niche avenue because it was so expensive, the increase in investment capital has altered its positioning of the program and placed it as mostly for the higher class audience. Due to this evaluation Behring Regional Center has argued that the acting Department of Homeland Security Officials failed to fully account for the adverse economic impact this rule would have on the program.

The Behring case which has been in court since December 2020 questions other regulations which were changed in November 2019 under the EB-5 modernization rule. The success of this case will result in the reversion of the capital investment back to $500,000 along with the other regulations such as the Targeted Employment Area (TEA) designation process.

Related: TikTok Will Pay $92M to Settle Lawsuit Over Personal Data 'Theft'

Does Behring Regional Center have a chance at winning this lawsuit?

Based on a similar case regarding legal authority in September 2020 the courts ruled that Chad Wolf ( acting Secretary of the Department of Homeland Security) was illegally appointed and thus his policies on asylum restrictions were blocked. In November his Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program was also blocked on the grounds that Chad Wolf was illegally appointed. Therefore, it can be assumed that there will be a similar ruling regarding the EB-5 program as he along with other officials were behind the enactment of the EB-5 modernized rule of 2019.

Related: Izzi Will Compensate Only 533 Users for Massive Failure in Its Service, Confirmed the Mexican Federal Consumer Prosecutor's Office

Will the reduction of the capital investment be forever?

We at the American Legal Center do not envision the capital amount to remain at $500,000 for long. It is possible that after a few months of the program being at $500,000 it will either go back to $900,000 or increase to keep up with the inflation rate. For families considering undertaking the process, we encourage you to contact us immediately and gain a free initial consultation to discuss your options. As of this moment a hearing is scheduled for 25 February 2021. We all continue to wait in anticipation.

Related: Jeff Bezos Demands $1.7 Million From His Girlfriend's Brother to Cover Legal Fees

Shai Zamanian

Managing Director at The American Legal Center

Shai Zamanian, a U.S. licensed lawyer and founder and director of the American Legal Center, assists families in the Middle East and Northern Africa (MENA) region migrate to the United States through investment immigration programs.

Want to be an Entrepreneur Leadership Network contributor? Apply now to join.

Business News

'Creators Left So Much Money on the Table': Kickstarter's CEO Reveals the Story Behind the Company's Biggest Changes in 15 Years

In an interview with Entrepreneur, Kickstarter CEO Everette Taylor explains the decision-making behind the changes, how he approaches leading Kickstarter, and his advice for future CEOs.

Business Ideas

87 Service Business Ideas to Start Today

Get started in this growing industry, with options that range from IT consulting to childcare.

Business Models

How to Become an AI-Centric Business (and Why It's Crucial for Long-Term Success)

Learn the essential steps to integrate AI at the core of your operations and stay competitive in an ever-evolving landscape.


5 Steps to Preparing an Engaging Industry Presentation

You can make a great impression and generate interest with an exciting, informative presentation. Find out my five secrets to creating an industry presentation guaranteed to wow.