New York Times to Invest in Startups Through Its Own Incubator The New York Times Co. plans to invest in early-stage media startups through its incubator, timeSpace, which recently graduated its inaugural class. Here's a look at what each of its three startups are up to.

By Brian Patrick Eha

Opinions expressed by Entrepreneur contributors are their own.

The New York Times Co. is going to invest in early-stage media startups through its incubator, timeSpace.

An experimental program within the newspaper company, timeSpace provided for three startups to spend the past four months collaborating with Times staffers and receiving crucial insight into the news industry and feedback as they developed their products.

When timeSpace was first announced in January, the Times Co. said it would not take equity in startups as part of the incubator program, though it left open the possibility of investing at a later date. Geoffrey Isenman, vice president of corporate development for the Times Co., broke the news at a press event Tuesday.

Isenman says the amount of the investment is still being debated, but that each company will receive the same deal. What's more, the next class of startups at timeSpace will receive the investment at the beginning of their tenure, he says.

On Tuesday, the startup founders who formed the incubator's inaugural class presented their companies. The Times Co. had winnowed a field of about 500 applicants down to three, each of them tackling a specific challenge in the media industry. All three companies were given coworking space on the ninth floor of the Times building, where they worked in the midst of Times staffers whose expertise they drew on while creating their startups.

Related: The New York Times Gets Into the Incubator Game

First up was Delve, a social news reader and recommendation engine designed to keep users on top of trends in their organization and industry. Co-founder and chief executive Sandeep Ayyappan spoke on the difficulty of separating signal from noise in today's growing flood of information. Valuable insights are lost. Even among coworkers, emails go unopened and tweets go unseen.

"You're only seeing a tiny sliver of all the interesting stuff that your colleagues are finding and sharing," Ayyappan said. "Delve changes that."

Delve's platform functions as a private social network for the employees of a given company. Each user receives personalized suggestions for what to read to stay current on her industry. Discussion tools make it easy to share knowledge with colleagues while keeping it away from competitors, and Delve archives everything so that you can find it later when you need it., Ayyappan said.

Delve's mobile app is awaiting approval in the Apple App store, he said.

Brian Muller of OpBandit, who presented next along with his co-founder, Blaine Sheldon, wants to help media companies be more relevant to their audiences. The key question, said Muller, is "What do you put front-and-center of all the content that you produce?" To answer that, OpBandit provides an analytics dashboard that tracks engagement metrics and allows site administrators to create alternate versions of each piece of content.

Related: Bloomberg Opens $75 Million Venture Capital Fund

With OpBandit, a news outlet's home page could be different for readers in one part of the country than for those in another, or could differ depending on time of day or other factors. For instance, some readers might see a different header image for a story than others. In short, OpBandit aims to promote the right version of the right content at the right time to maximize page views and engagement.

The final startup, Mahaya, demoed a product called Seen that represents an effort to curate "the real-time web" in which most news stories live and die. "Our social feeds are the first draft of history" now, having taken over that role from newspapers and cable TV news, said Tarikh Korula, Mahaya's co-founder. But social feeds are ephemeral; content disappears quickly, never to be seen again. In light of that, said Korula, "We're trying to create a coherent first draft."

To that end, Seen, which is in beta, tracks public events, scans social media for the best content surrounding them and displays it in a layout that looks like a cross between a Tumblr photo feed and a magazine spread. The content is archived and updated continually throughout the event, so Seen users can keep up on events of interest, everything from the Electric Zoo Festival to protests in Turkey.

Eventually, Seen hopes to function like "DVR for anything that happens in the world," Korula said.

For the Times Co., investing in digital startups is not new. Until now, however, it has done so only as an institutional investor at later stages in the life cycle of companies, and has never led a funding round, Isenman told Entrepreneur. That is what makes Wednesday's announcement such big news.

The purpose of the timeSpace investments is twofold, Isenman says. "One is financial, and the second is that notion of having skin in the game, and signaling our commitment."

Related: Inside Nerdist's Media Empire for the Internet Age

Wavy Line

Brian Patrick Eha is a freelance journalist and former assistant editor at He is writing a book about the global phenomenon of Bitcoin for Portfolio, an imprint of Penguin Random House. It will be published in 2015.

Editor's Pick

'Catastrophic': Here's What You Should Know About the Debt Ceiling Crisis — And How a Default Could Impact Your Business
I Helped Grow 4 Unicorns Over 10 Years That Generated $18 Billion in Online Revenues. Here's What I've Learned.
Want to Break Bad Habits and Supercharge Your Business? Use This Technique.
Don't Have Any Clients But Need Customer Testimonials? Follow These 3 Tricks To Boost Your Rep.
Why Are Some Wines More Expensive Than Others? A Top Winemaker Gives a Full-Bodied Explanation.

Related Topics


3 Negative Stories Entrepreneurs Tell Themselves (and How to Reframe Them)

Rewriting destructive narratives helps clarify thinking, facilitate growth and improve leadership.

Business News

Did the FBI Bust or Botch a Massive Chicago Stock Scam?

On this episode of 'Dirty Money,' we find out how the sausage was made in a legendary Chicago trading scandal.

Business News

7 of the 10 Most Expensive Cities to Live in the U.S. Are in One State

A new report by U.S. News found that San Diego is the most expensive city to live in for 2023-2024, followed by Los Angeles. New York City didn't even rank in the top 10.

Business News

More Americans Are Retiring Abroad, Without a Massive Nest Egg — Here's How They Made the Leap

About 450,000 people received their social security benefits outside the U.S. at the end of 2021, up from 307,000 in 2008, according to the Social Security Administration.

Money & Finance

3 Ways to Create Multiple (Big) Streams of Income

Here are three ways to create multiple streams of income. These strategies require effort and resources but offer significant financial potential.

Business News

'Devastated': Man Falls Overboard on Cruise in Bahamas, Fiancé Speaks Out

The man has been identified as 35-year-old Ronnie Lee Peale Jr.