Here's Why This Entrepreneur Gave Up Leadership of Her Successful Chocolate Company The co-founder and former CEO of Lily's Sweets decided the best thing for the company was to take a step back.

By Stephen J. Bronner Edited by Dan Bova

Courtesy Lily's Sweets
Cynthia Tice

Typically, when investors take over leadership of a business from its founder, it's a bad sign. But for Cynthia Tice and her chocolate business, Lily's Sweets, it was an acknowledgement that sometimes an entrepreneur is not the person best suited to lead a company as it grows.

"While I always believed Lily's would be successful, this expanding mainstream consumer awareness and desire for change created a groundswell for growth for Lily's Sweets beyond what I could have imagined," said Tice, who will remain at the company as its "conscious." "By 2017, I was aware that Lily's had outgrown our team of four people, two being my children, and my experience consulting other brands afforded me an appreciation of just how special Lily's was. I wanted to give the brand the opportunity that it deserved, and decided bringing on an investor and leadership that could grow a team would best set Lily's up to meet its full potential."

Image credit: Courtesy Lily's Sweets

Related: The Food Industry Is a 'Gold Rush' for Entrepreneurs, Says the Founder of Krave Jerky and a $40 Million Marshmallow Brand

Since I last featured Lily's Sweets in The Digest, the company received an undisclosed investment with VMG Partners and moved from a virtual workforce to an office in Boulder, Colo., the main hub of natural food in the U.S. The company said its business doubled in 2018, with its retail footprint expanding from 3,000 U.S. stores in 2017 to 10,000. Lily's has redesigned its packaging and plans to introduce new products, including chocolate covered peanuts and almonds and peanut butter cups, this year. Its team has expanded to 25, and is now led by Jane Miller, who has led a variety of food companies and had served as the division president of Frito-Lay at PepsiCo from 1984 to 1997.

"Most of my career in consumer packaged goods has been focused on fixing things, and this opportunity provided just the opposite scenario," Miller said. "With 84 percent of consumers looking to reduce their sugar intake, according to Mintel, I saw joining the Lily's Sweets team as an opportunity to continue the growth of something special."

Tice co-founded Lily's Sweets with its stevia-sweetened chocolate in 2011. The natural sweetener had been deemed as safe by the FDA only three years prior. Lily's launched nationally with Whole Foods in 2012.

Stephen J. Bronner

Entrepreneur Staff

News Director

Stephen J. Bronner writes mostly about packaged foods. His weekly column is The Digest. He is very much on top of his email.

Want to be an Entrepreneur Leadership Network contributor? Apply now to join.

Editor's Pick

Starting a Business

This 'Dream' Side Hustle Out-Earned Her Corporate Salary in 2 Years — Now It's a $2 Million Business

Here's the exact blueprint she used to leave her W2 job behind and step fully into entrepreneurship.

Business News

Deloitte Is Reimbursing Employees Up to $1,000 — For Buying Lego Sets

Each Deloitte employee can spend up to $1,000 on items to improve their well-being.

Business Ideas

70 Small Business Ideas to Start in 2025

We put together a list of the best, most profitable small business ideas for entrepreneurs to pursue in 2025.

Science & Technology

Tee Time With Investors? This Golf Trainer is a Must.

Sharpen your swing and your first impression before you hit the course.

Branding

Take Control of What Your Online Presence Says About You

5 steps to make your online presence work for you — not against you.

Starting a Business

The Next Chapter of Basketball? Why This New League Is Betting Big on 1v1 Hoops

The Next Chapter is a premier 1v1 league turning streetball culture into a marketable, competitive sport. With unique players and pay-per-view events, the league aims to become a billion-dollar basketball business.