Get All Access for $5/mo

The NYC Bagel Shop That Blew Up Thanks to 'Shark Tank' Just Got Acquired for $34 Million Bantam Bagels won funding from Lori Greiner to expand its business to retail.

By Stephen J. Bronner Edited by Dan Bova

Courtesy Bantam Bagels

Five years after Nick and Elyse Oleksak pursued a literal dream of stuffed bagels to found Bantam Bagels, the couple have sold the business to T. Marzetti Company (owned by the publicly traded Lancaster Colony Corporation) for $34 million.

The Oleksaks got their first big break after appearing on Shark Tank in 2014 and scoring a $275,000 investment from Lori Greiner. They then appeared on QVC.

"When you're an entrepreneur, you learn to live gut first," the Oleksaks said in a statement to Entrepreneur. "And finding the right business partner is kind of like picking the next member of your family. … With Marzetti, we will have the infrastructure and strategic support to grow Bantam exponentially, while being able to preserve the genuine authenticity that makes Bantam so great."

Related: This Bagel Shop Now Sells Products in 9,000 Stores Thanks to 'Shark Tank' and QVC

Along with a shop in New York City, Bantam's product line includes frozen bagels, pancakes and egg bites, which are sold in more than 9,000 retail locations, including Starbucks. Bantam Bagels' annual net sales are approximately $20 million.

The Oleksaks will stay on board with the company to run day-to-day operations and handle product development at Bantam, Lancaster said. The acquisition closed on Oct. 19.

"Part of what makes Bantam Bagels so great is the energy, authenticity and fire behind Nick, Elyse and the entire Bantam team," Dave Ciesinski, Lancaster Colony's CEO, said in a statement. "In acquiring Bantam Bagels, it's our goal to truly partner with them, enhancing the business where we can, but allowing Bantam and its products to flourish within the Lancaster Colony family. Food is so personal, and keeping Nick and Elyse and their founder's passion involved in the ongoing growth and development of Bantam is incredibly meaningful to us."

Stephen J. Bronner

Entrepreneur Staff

News Director

Stephen J. Bronner writes mostly about packaged foods. His weekly column is The Digest. He is very much on top of his email.

Want to be an Entrepreneur Leadership Network contributor? Apply now to join.

Employee Experience & Recruiting

Don't Just Hire — Grow Talent. 4 Ways to Set Your New Employees Up for Growth

When you hire new employees, you don't just fill the position but invest into the future of your company.

Business News

'Nonsense': T-Mobile CEO Balks at Reports That iPhone 16 Models Aren't Selling

The iPhone 16 hits store shelves Friday—without Apple Intelligence.

Growing a Business

He Replicated His Grandfather's 'Crazy' Business Strategy to Create a 'Wow Factor' Product You've Probably Seen in Whole Foods, Target and More

Jack Bessudo and Declan Simmons, co-founders of Tamalitoz by Sugarox, envisioned a product that would pay homage to both of their backgrounds.

Business News

Reese's Peanut Butter Cups Can Help You Get in Shape (Sorta)

Hershey announced a partnership with C4 Energy to make candy-flavored energy drinks and protein powders.

Growing a Business

At 24, She Was Fired From Her Advertising Job. Then an 'Incredibly Important' Mindset Helped Her Build a Multimillion-Dollar Business.

Melissa Ben-Ishay's brother Brian Bushell encouraged her to follow her passion — and it led to major success.

Personal Finance

This Free Portfolio Tracker Could Make You the Next Warren Buffett

Take control of your finances without hassle or hefty fees.