Ending Soon! Save 33% on All Access

Woman Accidentally Tipped $7,000 on Subway Sandwich — And Had to Fight the Bank to Get Her Money Back Vera Conner thought she was being prompted to enter her phone number on the Subway pay screen — but she quickly realized she made a grave mistake.

By Emily Rella Edited by Jessica Thomas

Key Takeaways

  • A woman in Georgia accidentally tipped $7,000 for her foot-long sub.
  • Conner thought the screen was asking her to enter her phone number to access her loyalty account with the chain, but it was really prompting her to enter a tip amount.
  • It took more than a month for her bank to reverse the charge, and she says it's a temporary credit.

Automatic tipping prompts have been wildly unpopular with customers at popular chain restaurants, but sometimes, human error can mean leaving an even bigger tip than the machine prompts.

This was precisely the case for Subway customer Vera Conner, who accidentally left a $7,105.44 tip on a $7.54 sandwich at a Georgia location of the chain.

Conner, who paid using a Bank of America credit card, accidentally input the last six digits of her cell phone number, thinking she was earning Subway loyalty points. But the screen had in fact asked her to enter the amount she wanted to leave for a tip.

Related: Starbucks Customers Are Furious Over New Digital Tipping System

"When I looked at my receipt, I was like, 'Oh, my God!'" Conner told NBC News. "Who would leave a tip like that?"

The charge, which Conner made on October 23, took nearly a month to reverse, which only happened after she made trips to the Subway store and bank and disputed the charge with Bank of America, which was initially denied.

"You hear all the time that you should use your credit card instead of your debit card so that these things don't happen," she told the outlet. "I'm even getting mad at the bank, because I'm like, 'How did they not think $7,000 was suspicious at Subway?'"

On Monday, the bank issued a temporary credit for the charge, but Conner noted that she will no longer be using the loyalty rewards app.

A spokesperson for Bank of America told the New York Post that the company "asked Subway to refund the money to the client and we're please[d] they have agreed to do so."

Subway did not immediately respond to Entrepreneur's request for comment.

Related: Oklahoma Man Charged $4,500 at Starbucks After Tipping Error

Emily Rella

Entrepreneur Staff

Senior News Writer

Emily Rella is a Senior News Writer at Entrepreneur.com. Previously, she was an editor at Verizon Media. Her coverage spans features, business, lifestyle, tech, entertainment, and lifestyle. She is a 2015 graduate of Boston College and a Ridgefield, CT native. Find her on Twitter at @EmilyKRella.

Want to be an Entrepreneur Leadership Network contributor? Apply now to join.

Editor's Pick

Growing a Business

Why I Choose to Publicly Share My Startup's Business Data on LinkedIn — And Why You Should Do the Same.

Here's why I'm sharing my startup's business data on LinkedIn, what data specifically, and how it has benefited my startup – and could benefit your company, too.

Business News

Sam's Club Is Removing a Beloved Free Perk and Members Are Not Happy: 'No Benefits for the Cost'

Disgruntled Sam's Club members are complaining on social media about the new change, effective August 19.

Health & Wellness

These Rapidly Growing Non-Alcoholic Beverages May Encourage A Damp July

If you want fewer hangovers, better sleep, more energy and weight loss, minimize your alcohol intake this summer with these alternatives that still elevate your mood.


There's Another Tax That Will Cost You In Big Ways If You Don't Do These 3 Things

Emotional tax is the interchange of energy and value. If you're depleted, this exchange of person or project is a cost. If you're energized and have received value, the exchange is a plus or profit. Learn three practical ways to kick overwhelm and lower your emotional tax for good.