Join our Waitlist for Expert Advice!

The Real Reason the Castaways Never Escaped Gilligan's Island Are you creating incentives for specific behaviors, but motivating people to do something completely different?

By Joel Basgall Edited by Dan Bova

Opinions expressed by Entrepreneur contributors are their own.

No matter how hard they tried, for three years and 98 episodes, the seven castaways on Gilligan's Island never got off the island.

Why did they fail to escape? They didn't really try because they weren't sufficiently motivated. Just like many employees and even company founders, they didn't have the right incentives.

The professor was happier on the island than off. Where else had he gained such respect and admiration? This brilliant scientist was able to generate electricity from a little human power and a few pulleys and capable of MacGyver-ing nearly anything from of coconuts and bamboo yet he couldn't build a transmitter from a radio or create a workable raft from the remains of the S.S. Minnow? Clearly the professor wanted to stay.

The skipper was a World War II naval veteran, a longtime boat captain and by all accounts a nautical genius. Yet his career wasn't flourishing: He chartered a ragtag collection of clients for short-term cruises. Yet somehow a man with his skills couldn't get them off the island either. Clearly the skipper wanted to stay.

Ginger, Mary Ann and the Howells didn't have the skills or experience to get the castaways off the island but they could motivate the professor and skipper. And what about Gilligan? He managed to screw up just about every attempt they made. Maybe that was on purpose. He could also elicit plenty of attention from everyone -- negative attention, sure, but attention nonetheless.

And yet somehow no one did anything to Gilligan. They never made hard choices. They didn't lock him up. They didn't finish him off. They did nothing dramatic enough to keep him from foiling their attempts to escape the island. They cared more about Gilligan than getting off the island.

The bottom line is that the castaways said they wanted to leave the island but their motivations and incentives weren't aligned.

Related: 5 Psychological Strategies for Building a Winning Team Culture

The same thing happens in business with employee compensation and incentive plans. Often managers think they are creating incentives for specific behaviors, but they are motivating employees to do something completely different.

For example, many companies compensate employees for writing higher quality code. How is this measured? Typically the metric is based on the number of bugs found. If there are no bugs detected, then the software must be of high quality. Yet that also means the software takes longer to build.

Other companies create incentives for employees to fix bugs but give employees reasons to ignore (or at least not worry about) issues during the development stage. That way the bugs can be found later, fixed and employees are compensated.

The problem is that leaders often struggle to articulate what they want as an outcome, so instead they compensate behaviors.

Related: How to Recruit Salespeople Who Will Deliver Dramatic Returns

Take salespeople. A behavioral approach to incentives is to provide compensation for making, say, 20 sales calls a day. If the company provides incentives for an individual to make 20 calls, he'll contact 20 individuals. He might not sell anything because whether or not those individuals are in any way interested or qualified sales leads doesn't matter: Twenty calls is 20 calls.

The outcome the company managers truly want is a sale, though, not the calls. Wouldn't you rather a salesperson make one call and achieve a sale rather than make 100 calls and achieve no sales?

But to define an outcome, the leader must have a tough conversation. He or she must be able to describe what's desired. Don't just define behaviors. Define success.

As a business owner, you have the power and the right to define what you want achieved. You have the right to define the outcome sought for the business, a goal, a project -- for anything.

Not only do you have power to define what you want. You also have the obligation. Your company can't become successful until you first define what success means -- and then compensate and provide incentives to employees to do what's necessary to achieve it.

This doesn't mean thinking about every possibility beforehand. What it means is that you need to define the outcome you want as well as you can and keep giving feedback to adjust the results along the way. Yes, it's a process of building understanding.

The castaways never got off the island because they didn't have a good reason to do so. On the island, no one dealt with that problem.

At your company, make sure you deal with the important problems -- or you'll never arrive where you want to be.

Related: 4 Reasons Sharing Performance Metrics Will Accelerate Your Business

Joel Basgall

CEO and Co-Founder, Geneca

Joel Basgall’s penchant for finding new ways to use ideas has propelled his career as the CEO of Geneca. His passion is using software to drive market innovation.

Want to be an Entrepreneur Leadership Network contributor? Apply now to join.

Business News

You Have One Month Left to Buy a House, According to Barbara Corcoran. Here's Why.

"If you are planning on waiting a year and seeing where interest rates go, you are out of your mind," Corcoran said.

Business News

Meta Fires Employee Making $400,000 Per Year Over a $25 Meal Voucher Issue

Other staff members were fired for the same reason, per a new report.

Franchise

The McRib Is Back, But Only at Select McDonald's — Here's Where to Find It

This scarcity is nothing new. In 2022, McDonald's announced a "Farewell Tour" for the McRib, suggesting that it might be the last time customers could get their hands on it.

Business News

These 3 Side Hustles Make the Most Money While Working Fewer Hours, According to a New Survey

The survey also found that having a side hustle doubled as a path to becoming more employable.

Business Ideas

63 Small Business Ideas to Start in 2024

We put together a list of the best, most profitable small business ideas for entrepreneurs to pursue in 2024.

Thought Leaders

These 3 Trends Will Change What It Means to Be an Entrepreneur in 2025

Here are three entrepreneurship trends from the new Global Entrepreneurship Monitor report that are changing the landscape for the future.