📺 Stream EntrepreneurTV for Free 📺

Should the U.S. President Have Business Experience? (Opinion) Why success in the private sector doesn't necessarily translate into an effective leadership.

By Scott Shane Edited by Dan Bova

entrepreneur daily

Opinions expressed by Entrepreneur contributors are their own.

Should the US President Have Business Experience

Mitt Romney thinks business experience should be a prerequisite for the American presidency. At a recent campaign rally, he said, "I'd like to have a provision in the Constitution . . . to say that the president has to spend at least three years working in business before he could become president of the United States."

While I think Romney would make a good president, he is way off base on this one. Almost every president has had some business-related experience. Even Barack Obama, whom Romney sought to criticize with this statement, has worked in a law firm.

But having business experience doesn't necessarily distinguish good presidents from bad ones. Sienna College Research Institute surveyed 238 presidential scholars to create a ranking of the top presidents. Of those the academic experts put in the top 10, six had some business experience. Abraham Lincoln started a general store, Harry Truman was a haberdasher, and James Madison, James Monroe, Thomas Jefferson and George Washington were planters.

Election 2012 - See where President Obama and Romney stand on Small Business IssuesAmong those presidents with business experience, the successful ones don't appear to be better at running the U.S. than unsuccessful ones. Both Lincoln and Truman ran businesses into the ground, but made it into the top 10. In fact, many of the presidents who were most successful in business don't rank very high among the nation's 43 chief executives. Consider Warren Harding, who ranked only two places from the bottom of the list. Yet before his 20th birthday, he borrowed money to buy a failing newspaper that generated income for the rest of his life. Herbert Hoover, a manager of a mining company, and George W. Bush, the first president with a master's in business administration degree and millionaire owner of the Texas Rangers, are both ranked in the bottom 10. And Jimmy Carter ranks only 32nd, even though he built a multimillion-dollar business from a family farm.

Fred Bernstein, emeritus professor of political science at Princeton University and author of numerous books on the presidency, says political and communication skills, organizational effectiveness, emotional stability and vision characterize successful presidents. While business experience can help develop these attributes, they can be formed in other ways, as well.

Consider vision, which presidential historian Arthur Schlesinger says is "the capacity to inspire." Being an entrepreneur or manager might help develop the "vision thing," but Ronald Reagan, Woodrow Wilson, and Theodore Roosevelt acquired it through other experiences.

Another key skill is the ability to organize, which Bernstein says includes the "ability to forge a team and get the most out of it, minimizing the tendency of subordinates to tell their boss what they sense he wants to hear, [and developing] proficiency at creating effective institutional arrangements." Once again, this skill can be developed in the private sector, but it can be learned through other experiences, too, such as being a governor or running a university.

Romney's justification for why presidents need business experience isn't terribly persuasive. He said that those with substantial business experience "would understand that the policies they're putting in place have to encourage small business, make it easier for business to grow." While business experience could be valuable, it certainly is possible to understand how policies will help small business without having run a business, just as it is possible to understand how to defend the country without having served in the military.

To the extent that business experience does matter, the Republican challenger needs to be careful. Big business and small business are very different. Romney's big business experience may have taught him little about what it takes to enhance small business performance.

In the business world, if your customers reject what you are selling, you need to move on quickly to something better. Romney might want to draw on his business experience and make that shift here.

Scott Shane

Professor at Case Western Reserve University

Scott Shane is the A. Malachi Mixon III professor of entrepreneurial studies at Case Western Reserve University. His books include Illusions of Entrepreneurship: The Costly Myths That Entrepreneurs, Investors, and Policy Makers Live by (Yale University Press, 2008) and Finding Fertile Ground: Identifying Extraordinary Opportunities for New Businesses (Pearson Prentice Hall, 2005).

Want to be an Entrepreneur Leadership Network contributor? Apply now to join.

Side Hustle

These Coworkers-Turned-Friends Started a Side Hustle on Amazon — Now It's a 'Full Hustle' Earning Over $20 Million a Year: 'Jump in With Both Feet'

Achal Patel and Russell Gong met at a large consulting firm and "bonded over a shared vision to create a mission-led company."

Business News

These Are the 10 Most Profitable Cities for Airbnb Hosts, According to a New Report

Here's where Airbnb property owners and hosts are making the most money.

Side Hustle

How to Turn Your Hobby Into a Successful Business

A hobby, interest or charity project can turn into a money-making business if you know the right steps to take.


Want to Be More Productive? Here's How Google Executives Structure Their Schedules

These five tactics from inside Google will help you focus and protect your time.

Starting a Business

This Couple Turned Their Startup Into a $150 Million Food Delivery Company. Here's What They Did Early On to Make It Happen.

Selling only online to your customers has many perks. But the founders of Little Spoon want you to know four things if you want to see accelerated growth.