You can be on Entrepreneur’s cover!

3 Ways to Use a Rivalry to Increase Your Business Performance Unlike competition, rivalry is personal, and it can either have a profoundly positive or negative impact on overall performance.

By Laura Entis

entrepreneur daily

Opinions expressed by Entrepreneur contributors are their own.

At the heart of some of the most stunning displays of human achievement lies an intense rivalry. From the software wars between tech heavyweights Bill Gates and Steve Jobs, to the grueling matches between tennis greats Pete Sampras and Andre Agassi, to the fraught, acrimonious relationship between Earnest Hemingway and F. Scott Fitzgerald, rivalry has incited staggeringly high levels of achievement from individuals and organizations across industries.

To be clear: Rivalry and competition, while similar, are not synonymous. Teasing apart their subtle but important differences helps explain why rivalry makes for such a potent motivator, says Gavin Kilduff, a professor at NYU's Stern School of Business.

Competition, as Kilduff defines it, is any situation in which the goals or outcomes of the actors involved are opposed to one another, so a gain for one player inherently comes at a loss for the other. Rivalry is more personal; it's built on relationships.

Kilduff has been studying the topic for years, and his research indicates that rivalries typically develop when competitors are similar (in age, demographic etc.), they compete against one another frequently and their skillsets are evenly matched. Intuitively, it makes sense that striving to beat someone who competes at or just above our level and with whom we have a long track record will increase both effort and performance; winning is suddenly very personal. Indeed, by analyzing a roster of competitive runners, Kilduff found that competitors running in a race with a rival whittled down their time by an average of five seconds per kilometers.

Undoubtedly, rivalry is a tool that can be used to boost both effort and performance. But it's very much a double-edged sword, Kilduff finds; left unchecked and allowed to develop in unfavorable conditions, it can fester into a warped motivator; suddenly, success is measured solely by how we stack up against a single competitor. Kilduff's research has found that participants who are asked to think about a personal rival before performing a task are far more likely to inflate their actual performance than participants who are simply asked to think about a competitor.

Related: How You Compete Matters More Than Winning Or Losing

When going head-to-head with a rival, motivation can easily become untethered from what's at stake, because "beating that opponent carries a psychological value in and of itself independent of the size of the prize," Kilduff says. And that can be dangerous: Laser-focusing in on one rival at the expense of the bigger picture leaves us vulnerable to "other competitive threats that may be newly emerging."

So how can individuals and organizations harness rivalry to increase motivation, effort and performance without falling victim to its darker side?

1. Consider the task at hand.

Rivalry is a great motivator to try harder, so in general, it works best in situations where the link between effort and performance is strong. For example, rivalries -- particularly between friends -- can be a great boost in areas like personal health and fitness, or other activities that require effort and dedication, such as studying for an exam.

"We're discovering more and more that having someone you are a little competitive with, who you compare your progress to, can be a very motivating force," says Kilduff, who admits he has a couple friends with whom he maintains a "moderate level" of rivalry.

However, for tasks where the relationship between effort and performance is less direct -- for jobs that require creativity or precision, say -- Kilduff warns that intense rivalries can frequently backfire and actually discourage progress, as the "extra arousal and excitement" of intense competition easily becomes a distraction.

2. Don't allow rivalries to develop unchecked -- especially when lying and cheating is possible.

In one of Kilduff's studies, he had subjects face-off against a simulated opponent to complete a typing contest. The study was designed so that each participant won two out of the four contests, but half the group faced off against the same opponent each time and won or lost by a narrow margin; these slight victories and losses to the same opponent encouraged feelings of rivalry among participants, who subsequently reported higher scores on the Machiavellianism scale. No money was at stake here, so imagine the potential shift in a person's personality when real cash and prestige is on the line.

Related: 5 Ways to Boost Your Willpower

Outside of the lab, Kilduff studied rivalry's side effects on the soccer field. By analyzing games between professional Italian soccer teams, he found that matches played between intra-city rivals resulted in a substantially higher number of red and yellow cards, a fairly good indicator of unethical behavior in sports because cards are typically awarded for dangerous tackles or attempts to deceive a referee by taking a dive.

It appears, then, that unregulated rivalry doesn't just incite cheating and lying; it incites risky actions as well. Encouraging intense rivalries between employees who have "leeway to engage in risky or unethical behavior, take dangerous gambles or fudge the numbers," is a recipe for unethical behavior, Kilduff warns (financial industry, take note).

3. Encourage organizational rivalries.

While rivalries between individual employees can be an effective motivator, they can also easily backfire, increasing tension and the temptation to cheat or lie on the job.

Rather than advising employers to pit co-workers against one another, Kilduff recommends encouraging rivalries at the organizational level. For most businesses, identifying a competitor and then focusing on outperforming them can increase motivation and identification within the organization.

In Kilduff's most recent research, which has yet to be published, he finds that U.S. universities engaged in a long-standing rivalry (Harvard vs. Yale, USC vs. UCLA) benefit from increased merchandise sales, as well as a a higher proportion of alumni who donate to the school, even after controlling for factors like academic and athletic rank.

"It seems like the rivalry is triggering a higher level of identification and commitment among the organizational members," Kilduff says. "That could certainly apply to businesses as well as universities."

Related: How Competition Created an Industry That Changed the World

Laura Entis is a reporter for's Venture section.

Want to be an Entrepreneur Leadership Network contributor? Apply now to join.

Side Hustle

This Dad Started a Side Hustle to Save for His Daughter's College Fund — Then It Earned $1 Million and Caught Apple's Attention

In 2015, Greg Kerr, now owner of Alchemy Merch, was working as musician when he noticed a lucrative opportunity.

Growing a Business

Bantam Bagels' Founder Fell Into a Mindset Trap 'People Don't Talk About' After Selling the Now-Defunct Business for $34 Million — Here's What Happened

Elyse Oleksak and her husband Nick founded their mini bagel business in 2013 — and it was an instant hit.

Business News

I Designed My Dream Home For Free With an AI Architect — Here's How It Works

The AI architect, Vitruvius, created three designs in minutes, complete with floor plans and pictures of the inside and outside of the house.

Money & Finance

Setting Your Business Up for Success Through the Rest of 2024

CFO's mid-year update: Understanding the latest trends and regulations impacting business finance.

Business News

Yes, You Can Buy a Foldable Tiny Home on Amazon — And Now It's Selling for Less Than $12,000

The waterproof and flameproof house was listed around $35,000 a few months ago.

Thought Leaders

We Live in a Data-Driven World — Here's a Case For Listening to Your Gut Instead

Honing and trusting one's intuition can lead to quicker, more effective decision-making. Here's how to harness the power of listening to your gut to make the best choices.