Why Would We Expect Wearables to Get Calories Right When We Usually Don't? A recent study from Stanford shows that wearable devices are pretty terrible at tracking calories.

By Stephen J. Bronner

Shutterstock

Maintaining a healthy body weight is more than a matter of calories in, calories out. Genetics play a role, and they could determine your predisposition to obesity. Scientists are only now scratching the surface of the potential influence gut bacteria have on health. But despite these complicating factors, it's important to understand: What the heck is a calorie?

The origins of the term can be traced back to a few French scientists. It was defined as a measurement of the heat needed to raise the temperature of a kilogram of water from 32 degrees Fahrenheit to 33.8 degrees. Eventually, it came to define how much heat, or energy, what we consume provides our bodies.

Related: 5 Ways Switching to Plant-Based Diet Boosts Your Productivity

So when you look at that bag of chips and it says eating the whole thing would be 400 calories, that essentially means your body will have to work ever so much to burn it off. Except, not really. Nutritionists have established that in fact, all calories are not equal. Eating 400 calories worth of chips is not the same as eating 400 calories worth of vegetables. And yet again, each of our bodies works differently, so you may eat those chips and come out OK, whereas I would eat those chips and gain weight.

All of this is to say that, a recent study from Stanford which shows wearable devices are pretty terrible at tracking calories isn't too surprising. How can we expect our tech to understand calories when we ourselves don't?

For the study, 60 volunteers -- 31 women and 29 men -- wore the devices (participants tested the Apple Watch, Basis Peak, Fitbit Surge, Microsoft Band, Mio Alpha 2, PulseOn and the Samsung Gear S2) while walking or running on treadmills or using stationary bicycles. All were also fitted with medical equipment. The researchers then compared the results of the medical instruments to the wearables and found huge discrepancies. (To their credit, the wearables were pretty good at tracking heart rate.)

Related: Live a Healthier Life by Making Consistency Work for You

"People are basing life decisions on the data provided by these devices," said Euan Ashley, a professor of cardiovascular medicine, genetics and biomedical data science at Stanford who led the study. "The energy expenditure measures were way off the mark. The magnitude of just how bad they were surprised me."

He made sure to add that eating doughnuts because your wearable says you burned a certain number of calories is a really bad idea.

By no means am I saying that we should ignore calories -- they're the best unit of measurement of food that we've got, and sticking to a lower-calorie diet can help you lose weight. But we also need to be aware that the human body is complicated, and we're not even close to understanding all of its great mysteries just yet.

Wavy Line
Stephen J. Bronner

Entrepreneur Staff

News Director

Stephen J. Bronner writes mostly about packaged foods. His weekly column is The Digest. He is very much on top of his email.

Editor's Pick

A Leader's Most Powerful Tool Is Executive Capital. Here's What It Is — and How to Earn It.
Lock
One Man's Casual Side Hustle Became an International Phenomenon — And It's on Track to See $15 Million in Revenue This Year
Lock
3 Reasons to Keep Posting on LinkedIn, Even If Nobody Is Engaging With You
Why a Strong Chief Financial Officer Is Crucial for Your Franchise — and What to Look for When Hiring One

Related Topics

Business News

The Virgin Islands Want to Serve Elon Musk a Subpoena, But They Can't Find Him

Government officials would like to talk to Tesla's owner as part of an investigation into the Jeffrey Epstein case.

Health & Wellness

3 Breathing Techniques to Help You De-Stress and Refocus in the Moment

Executive coach and author Susan S. Freeman shares these exercises to center yourself during chaotic times in her new book, 'Inner Switch: 7 Timeless Principles to Transform Modern Leadership.'

Growing a Business

Andy Hooper of Hart House on Pioneering a Plant-Based Revolution

Interview with Andy Hooper of Hart House about co-founding the modern restaurant company with Kevin Hart, making plant-based food accessible to all, and investing in employees.

Leadership

Are These 17 Biases Affecting You as a Leader? The Answer Is Likely Yes — Here's How to Address Them.

Having biases is an inherent part of being human, but that doesn't mean we don't have the responsibility to manage them and make sure they don't impact the way we lead.

Franchise

Franchise Ownership Made Easy: Best Practices for Managing and Growing Your Business

Using these tips, you can maximize the benefits of franchise ownership and take your business to the next level.