Preventing the Spread of Conspiracy Theories in Times of Crisis Requires Effective Leadership Lack of transparency, bad communication, and cynicism provides fertile soil for conspiracism to take root and spread within an organization.

By Joel B. Carnevale

Opinions expressed by Entrepreneur contributors are their own.

FangXiaNuo | Getty Images

In a recent Entrepreneur article, I discussed some of the reasons we often fall prey to conspiracy theories during moments of crisis, describing how our desire for control, cognitive biases, and narcissism can spur such toxic thinking. The primary focus of that article was one of personal agency, as the onus is largely on us to be mindful of our own susceptibility to conspiracy thinking.

However, because conspiracies often attribute culpability for a crisis or unseen event to those who are in a position of authority, it's also important to understand the role leaders play in influencing the emergence and spread of conspiracism in the wake of dynamic events. After all, research shows that not only can leaders contribute to employees' conspiracism, but such beliefs can reduce employee commitment and even lead to increased turnover. Below, I focus on how leaders' lack of transparency, disingenuous communication, and own paranoia and cynicism, may provide fertile soil for conspiracism to take root and spread within their organization. Although I focus specifically on the interplay of leadership and conspiracism as it relates to organizations, the implications extend to leadership at the societal level as well.

Related: The Future of Leadership is Empathy — and Companies Are Better for It

Pay no attention to the man behind the curtain

The problems leaders encounter during periods of uncertainty are, by definition, unstructured and ambiguous. Because the criteria and solutions to such problems are often ill-defined, leaders may frequently find themselves needing to modify existing plans and potentially change course as they encounter new data and information. When navigating such environments, it can be enticing to keep your employees at a distance, fearing that you may be seen as indecisive or unable to handle the situation should you need to change strategy in light of new information. As tempting as this might be, such a lack of transparency during moments of crisis is a mistake, and will only serve to fuel dissidence, rumors, and conspirational thinking among your ranks. Instead, keep employees informed of the process and actively invite their opinions and suggestions when making decisions. As research shows, when leaders exhibit such high levels of transparency during turbulent events, they are likely to be perceived as more trustworthy and effective by those they lead, key elements needed to keep conspiracism at bay.

Related: 4 Steps for Leaders Building a 'We' Culture in Their Business

Cut the bullshit

Reducing the spread of conspiracism during times of crisis also requires leaders to be mindful of how they are communicating with their employees. Despite the colloquial use of the term, the concept of bullshit has been the subject of academic interest. Bullshit goes beyond mere dishonesty, as it involves communication that is not only untruthful but unconnected from truth entirely. That is, unlike lying, which necessitates the liar to know what the truth is, the bullshiter need not know the truth at all. Such style of communication is often prevalent during moments of crisis, as leaders may feel compelled to provide answers to problems for which there are not yet solutions. For example, leaders may attempt to feign control over the situation by conveying a false sense of optimism, misrepresenting the true state of events, or making promises they can't fulfill. Yet, such behaviors not only convey a lack of respect for employees but, when seen for what it is, can sow distrust and cynicism toward leadership, thereby fueling the flames of conspiracism. Accordingly, opt instead for communication that is honest, candid, and consistent with reality – even if the reality is more uncertainty.

Related: How Leaders Build More Resilient Teams

Monkey see, monkey do

Within organizations, employees naturally look to those around them, including their direct superiors, to help them make sense of their environment. This sense-making process can be quite useful, as it can facilitate socialization processes and strengthen the organization's culture. However, during moments of crisis, it also can serve as a conduit for conspiracism to spread. For example, research suggests that leaders' own paranoia and cynicism during moments of crisis can influence employees' conspiratorial thinking, as it can foster a sense of distrust and skepticism toward the organization. Accordingly, it's important to ensure that, across all levels of the organizational hierarchy, those who are in a position of authority are modeling the appropriate behavior and not undermining your efforts to manage the crisis with their own conspiratorial beliefs.

Joel B. Carnevale

Entrepreneur Leadership Network® Contributor

Assistant Professor of Management at Syracuse University

Joel Carnevale is an assistant professor of management at Syracuse University’s Martin J. Whitman School of Management. His research focuses on leadership, creativity and behavioral ethics at work.

Editor's Pick

Related Topics

Growing a Business

What It Takes to Build a Best-In-Class Company — 3 Essential Elements

The journey to excellence is not a matter of chance but a deliberate pursuit to shape the future and raise the bar for all who follow.

Business News

McDonald's Is Making a Major Change to Its Burgers in 2024

The beloved Big Mac will also be getting a big makeover.

Business News

A Judge Blocked a U.S. State's Attempt to Ban TikTok for All Residents — Here's Why

Montana residents would have faced $10,000 fines for using the app.

Marketing

5 Tips for Helping Your Book Stand Out In an Overcrowded Niche

Writing a book is one thing. Getting people to read it is an entirely different kind of challenge.

Growing a Business

Serial Entrepreneur Turned VC Reveals 4 Numbers You Need to Know to Scale Your Company

If you're looking to attract investment or simply seeking to scale your business, there are four key numbers you should use as your guiding light.

Growing a Business

Queen Latifah Says Female Leaders Need to Do These 4 Things to Succeed

The celebrated actress, entertainer and entrepreneur has strong advice for women in business.