Carlotta Thompson on the ‘December 31 Wall’: Why Many Accountants Don’t Deliver Tax Planning
The former IRS auditor says filing-season conversations often come too late for many tax-saving moves, highlighting a structural challenge in how tax planning is delivered.
Business owners sometimes ask why a tax-saving idea was not raised sooner. Carlotta Thompson, founder of Tax Strategists of America and a former Internal Revenue Service auditor, has a view on one reason this happens. In her opinion, the timing of the tax calendar can make it difficult for planning advice to arrive while there is still time to act on it. She calls this the “December 31 Wall.”
The idea rests on two sets of dates. Federal filing deadlines run through much of the year, with individual returns generally due in April and extended returns due in September and October.
Tax planning often runs on a different timeline. As CNBC has reported, most year-end planning moves must be completed by December 31 to count for that tax year, though some, such as certain IRA and health savings account contributions, can be made up to the following year’s filing deadline. Thompson argues that a strategy identified during filing season is often, in practice, a strategy for the next year.
“There are a few things you can do after the year closes, but only a few,” Thompson says. “You cannot go backwards and change what you did. When the client’s return is due, that conversation is already historical. That is the wall.”
According to Thompson, Tax Strategists of America, formerly Carlotta Thompson & Associates, was set up as a separate business to focus on tax strategy. She says the firm now runs tax planning and tax preparation as separate companies with separate management.
“We did everything under one roof at the start, and I thought that was the correct way to do it,” Thompson says. “Even in my own company, the management team defaulted to the current-year deadline every time. That is not a discipline problem. It is a structural one. When your license depends on a filing date, the filing date wins.”
Thompson also points to a gap in expectations. In her experience, some business owners assume a tax preparation fee includes forward-looking planning, while the engagement may only cover compliance. She says this difference is not always discussed clearly at the start.
“I teach accountants, and this is what they raise most often,” she says. “Their clients are irritated because they believed strategy was included. It was never in the engagement.”
Many accounting firms do offer planning, and the profession has been moving in that direction. A 2025 Wolters Kluwer report found that 94% of U.S. firms offer advisory or consulting services, with automation and AI helping to take on routine tasks as firms expand that work. Firms are also changing how compliance work gets done. The Journal of Accountancy has reported on CPA firms using offshore teams for parts of the tax preparation process.
Thompson’s broader point is about how the work is organized. She describes compliance work as recurring, deadline-driven and easier to price. She describes planning work as less frequent, more technical, and sometimes dependent on outside specialists for items such as cost segregation studies and research credits. In her view, when both kinds of work compete for the same staff time late in the year, filing deadlines tend to come first. Industry research points to related pressures: Wolters Kluwer’s review of firm challenges lists capacity constraints among the top issues for smaller firms and notes that operational strain can lead to missed advisory opportunities.
Tax Strategists of America offers one approach. The firm says it works alongside clients’ existing accountants rather than replacing them, and passes implemented strategies back to them for use at the preparation stage. According to the firm, roughly half its clients have their returns prepared elsewhere. Other firms handle planning in-house, through dedicated advisory teams or year-round planning services.
It is too early to say whether separating planning from preparation will become a wider model. For business owners, one practical step is to confirm what their current engagement includes and when planning conversations will take place during the year.
The information provided in this article is for general informational and educational purposes only. It is not intended as financial or professional advice. Readers should not rely solely on the content of this article and are encouraged to seek professional advice tailored to their specific circumstances. We disclaim any liability for any loss or damage arising directly or indirectly from the use of, or reliance on, the information presented.
Entrepreneur Media was not involved in the creation of this content.