Contributor Content What's This?

He Was Ridiculed for Asking Why Knees Couldn’t Be Repaired Instead of Replaced. 35 Years Later, He’s Building a Company to Change That.

Marc P. Pietropaoli, MD, built Victory In Motion around a question he first asked in medical school about repairing damaged knees rather than replacing them.

By Matthew Kayser | Nov 17, 2026
Image Credit: Victory In Motion

Dr. Marc P. Pietropaoli recalls watching Dr. David Murray, a pioneer of knee replacement surgery, guide a chief resident through a knee replacement in 1991, when Pietropaoli was a third-year medical student. 

A junior resident had told him there was no such thing as a dumb question. Pietropaoli raised his hand.

“Is there a way to cure arthritis? Is there a way to grow back new cartilage? Is there a way to repair a knee and not replace it?”

Before Murray could answer, the chief resident pointed at him and shot him down: no, no, and no. Pietropaoli felt two inches tall.

“Someday, I’m going to prove that guy wrong,” he remembers thinking.

He stopped asking for a while. By residency, he was asking again and still getting dismissed. Later, as a practicing surgeon, he was criticized for performing fewer traditional operations.

Today, Pietropaoli is the founder and CEO of Victory In Motion, a knee care practice in Skaneateles, N.Y. The company has set a goal of ending the need for knee replacements by 2043. 

“Our mission is bold, measurable, and bigger than me. It’s bigger than one physician, one team, or one company. Victory In Motion is the engine to help accomplish it, but the mission is what matters,” he says.

The question becomes personal

After a sports medicine fellowship, Pietropaoli founded his practice in 2001.

The Victory Method™ combines comprehensive diagnostics, individualized treatment planning, regenerative medicine, orthobiologics, advanced laser technologies, and V-Motion Fit™ — Total Body Fitness, Strength & Conditioning. Innovative knee repair surgery is incorporated when medically indicated.

While there is industry debate about regenerative orthopedics, he says most knee patients at his practice can improve without surgery, including through comprehensive regenerative medicine programs. When surgery is needed, his priority is repairing and preserving the natural knee whenever possible.

Pietropaoli says his father’s experience with an infected hip replacement made the mission personal. His father later passed away, and the experience strengthened his commitment to preserving natural joints. 

A different patient experience

Patients frequently tell Pietropaoli that their healthcare providers spend just 10–15 minutes with them face-to-face, often leaving them feeling rushed and unheard.

At Victory In Motion, patients can undergo Clarity Day™, a four- to five-hour Comprehensive Diagnostic Evaluation. The experience includes 60–90 minutes or longer face-to-face with a regenerative medicine provider, advanced imaging with digital X-rays, dynamic ultrasound and open MRI, and a one-hour V-Motion Fit evaluation of Total Body Fitness, Strength & Conditioning.

According to Victory In Motion, patients receive a diagnosis and individualized treatment plan that same day, which may include a Victory Method program for those who qualify. 

After a four-year transition beginning in 2021, Victory In Motion completed its move away from traditional insurance billing on January 1, 2025.

Its comprehensive knee programs combine platelet-rich plasma (PRP), bone marrow aspirate cells, laser therapy, V-Motion Fit and surgery when necessary.

A first in the operating room

On October 29, 2021, Pietropaoli performed the first FDA-indicated Bridge-Enhanced ACL Restoration/Repair (BEAR) surgery outside clinical trials anywhere in the world.

Unlike conventional ACL reconstruction, which substitutes a tendon graft for a torn ligament, BEAR uses a biologic implant and the patient’s own blood to help the patient’s own ACL regrow and heal.

Measuring success

Victory In Motion says it tracks patient-reported outcomes from its regenerative medicine treatments through DataBiologics, a national outcomes research registry. 

The reported DataBiologics results place Victory In Motion in the 98th percentile for pain improvement and the 96th percentile for functional improvement, with 95% patient satisfaction at six months.

These figures reflect participating patients’ reports. They do not guarantee an individual result.

“No treatment works 100% of the time — not surgery, and not regenerative medicine,” Pietropaoli says. “Ninety-five percent satisfaction is encouraging, but it doesn’t mean we’re finished. We want to keep getting better.”

A surgeon learns to be a CEO

The bigger challenge was no longer surgical. Pietropaoli recognizes that neither he nor even his team can accomplish the 2043 mission alone. If the model depended on him alone, it could never spread far enough.

“It’s definitely not about me. We have to build teams, train others to deliver this care, and track their results,” he says. “That’s how we exponentially multiply the impact.”

He has also written Repair NOT Replace™, which includes a foreword by Dr. Andrews, and discusses his approach through seminars and webinars. 

According to Victory In Motion, he also travels within the United States and internationally to speak about his approach to knee preservation. 

But the business must do more: train and support teams far beyond Skaneateles.

The Victory Method is already established. The next challenge is standardizing its delivery, expanding access, training more healthcare professionals and measuring outcomes as additional teams adopt the approach.

The mission starts before the injury

A torn anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) increases the risk of developing knee arthritis, which can eventually lead to knee replacement.

Preventing ACL tears in the first place means fewer people facing that risk.

That is why Dr. Pietropaoli wants evidence-based ACL injury prevention programs implemented in every youth sports league, school and college athletics program nationwide.

Is 2043 realistic?

Knee replacements remain necessary for some patients today, and demand is growing. Dr. Pietropaoli knows how ambitious the mission sounds.

He remembers how his original question sounded in 1991.

“Your age should never determine the size of your dreams or limit what you believe is possible,” he says. “Do not allow your past failures to define your future. I genuinely believe my greatest accomplishments are still ahead of me.”

Thirty-five years ago, a chief resident shut down his question in an operating room.

Today, the mission it inspired is painted on his company’s wall:

End The Need For Knee Replacements By 2043.

This article is for informational purposes only and does not substitute for professional medical advice. If you are seeking medical advice, diagnosis or treatment, please consult a medical professional or healthcare provider.

Entrepreneur Media was not involved in the creation of this content.