For Subscribers

Three Questions to Ask Your Payroll Service How to evaluate whether your payroll service is working for your business.

By Gwen Moran Edited by Frances Dodds

Opinions expressed by Entrepreneur contributors are their own.

Scott Bloom was tired of hearing the complaints. The payroll service he hired to handle payroll needs for his businesses performed well in the beginning. But suddenly the outfit was missing payroll checks and sending incorrect reports.

"They never submitted a wrong return to the IRS or state, but a couple of times I had to write checks out of the business account to get employees their paychecks on time," says Bloom, who owns Bloom Real Estate Group and is a principal of Powerhouse Business Brokers, both based in New York.

"Payroll is such an important piece [of your business], with critical penalties if it's not handled correctly, so you need to be sure you're working with a skilled provider," says Steven J. Elliott, tax director at Schwartz & Co., an accounting firm in Bellmore, N.Y.

It's a good idea to give your payroll service a checkup now and again to be sure you're getting the best service at the best value, Elliott advises. He suggests asking the following questions.

Where to Look
Many accounting and bookkeeping firms offer payroll services, so going local with a reputable firm is always an option. If you're looking for bigger fish, here are some popular options

ADP
CompuPay
Intuit Online Payroll
Paychex

Do they offer guarantees? From time to time, mistakes happen. When they happen with payroll submissions handled by a third-party provider, the penalties and interest can still be steep--and your responsibility. Ask what kind of protections the company offers in the case of mistakes and who pays the penalties and interest. "Most of these companies will pay the penalties if they make a mistake, but few will also take responsibility for the interest," Elliott says.

Are you using the services you pay for? If you just need paycheck services, you shouldn't have to pay for other bundled services you don't need. Many of the larger providers offer services like tax-compliance assistance, insurance services and time-sheet management. Be sure your provider allows you to pick only the services you need.

What's their track record? Bloom's staff asked around and got recommendations of other payroll services before making a switch. Elliott suggests doing basic due diligence--search for complaints about the service online and check in with the Better Business Bureau and your state's department of banking to see if complaints have been issued, especially if you're considering working with a smaller provider.

Gwen Moran

Writer and Author, Specializing in Business and Finance

GWEN MORAN is a freelance writer and co-author of The Complete Idiot's Guide to Business Plans (Alpha, 2010).

Want to be an Entrepreneur Leadership Network contributor? Apply now to join.

Business News

Elon Musk Gives One-Sentence Response to Linda Yaccarino Stepping Down as CEO of X

Linda Yaccarino announced on Tuesday that she was leaving her role as X's chief executive.

Business News

Here's the Exact Amount of Money You Need to Be Wealthy, According to a Charles Schwab Survey

Financial service giant Charles Schwab's annual Modern Wealth Survey reveals some eye-popping numbers.

Thought Leaders

How to Build Thought Leadership That Fuels Growth, Earns Trust and Positions You as an Industry Leader

Follow this proven three-part formula that transforms organizational expertise into market influence through strategic research and content activation.

Money & Finance

Don't Let Slow-Paying Customers Slow Your Business Down. Here's Your Playbook for Getting Paid on Time.

Respectful, consistent pressure can encourage hesitant customers to pay promptly, enabling your business to thrive.

Leadership

Why Sharing the CEO Title Usually Ends in Disaster

Two co-founders often think they can share the executive responsibilities as co-CEOs. This article will teach you why that is typically never going to work out as planned and will simply cause grief for the co-CEOs, staff and your investors.

Business Ideas

70 Small Business Ideas to Start in 2025

We put together a list of the best, most profitable small business ideas for entrepreneurs to pursue in 2025.