What Matters More, the Quality or Size of Your Social Media Audience?

Should brands seek to bring on as many followers on as many platforms as possible?

learn more about Deborah Mitchell

By Deborah Mitchell • May 26, 2015

Quka | Shutterstock.com

Opinions expressed by Entrepreneur contributors are their own.

For some brands, massive social media numbers -- whether their own or bloggers they are considering for campaigns -- takes precedence over anything else. This leaves me to ask, when it comes to followers and "likes," does quantity trump quality?

Social media manager Jason Francis, of Social Media Samurai, says that "Quality trumps all. I know people with 30,000 followers struggling to raise $500 in a GoFundMe campaign, while people with 2,000 to 3,000 followers can move and influence them to the tune of $25,000."

Related: The Tools and Strategies You Need to Track Every Important Social Conversation

In an informal poll of social media managers, I asked, "What do you tell clients and brands that worry about the number of social media followers?"

Diane Leone, founder and digital media strategist for Butterfly Social, a boutique social media agency that helps companies market their businesses using social media, goes through an evaluation process to identify the top three social media platforms that will work best for clients' businesses.

"It's about focusing on one or two of the best platforms for your business and really building quality connections on those platforms," she says. "If you try to spread yourself thin, whether it's across all social media platforms or trying to get huge quantities of followers, how will you engage with all of them effectively? I advise clients to go for meaningful engagements."

Social media strategies are different for each business, but the consensus in the poll was that 80 percent quality and 20 percent quantity is an effective formula.

Social media strategist and business coach Sofia Pacifico, of Increase Your Social Media Reach, says she believes brands should get the quality on top and the quantity that is relevant for the business will follow.

"What I would say is: Do you want engaging and loyal customers coming to your door regularly? Or do you want a business full of people just 'window shopping' and actually not interested in your services and leaving empty handed?" she asks.

Related: 3 Measures of Online Business That Aren't as Important as Entrepreneurs Think

The key to quality followers is authenticity in your engagement. The obsession with higher numbers has some brands seeking out "fake followers." Yes, you can buy followers.

Digital Megaphone founder and CEO Hope Bertram promotes authenticity.

"Something I always recommend to brands I work with is to make sure they are working with influencers who are building real audiences," she says. "The website fakers.statuspeople.com is an amazing resource in checking to see if people's Twitter followers are real. It drives me bonkers to see 'influencers' with fake audiences."

The end goal should be to have the best of both worlds of quality and quantity, says Jarem Atkinson, a social marketing manager.

"But gone are the days where simply having 'likes' makes a Facebook page relevant or credible," Atkinson says. "Actual engagement is what creates value for any company, brand, or individual on Facebook. And you can only get real engagement and community by having quality followers."

Related: How to Build a Social-Media Strategy That Works

Deborah Mitchell

CEO & Founder, Deborah Mitchell Media Associates

Emmy-nominated network television producer Deborah Mitchell is a veteran of ABC and CBS News, a member of the Producers Guild of America, and a board member of the James Beard Broadcast and Media Awards Committee. Through Deborah Mitchell Media Associates she will create your online personality with a customized website, book you on the right television show, manage your social media profiles and finally connect you with the best and brightest digital influencers. Mitchell is author of So You Want To Be On TV

Related Topics

Editor's Pick

Have More Responsibilities at Work, But No Pay Bump? Use This Script to Get the Raise You Deserve.
Black and Asian Founders Face Opposition at All Levels — Here's Why That Has to Change
Business News

Frontier Airlines Just Announced Its All-You-Can-Fly Summer Pass for $399. What's the Catch?

As travel begins to pick up, the airline hopes unlimited travel will jumpstart its business.

Thought Leaders

5 Small Daily Habits Self-Made Millionaires Use to Grow Their Wealth

We've all seen what self-made millionaires look like on TV, but it's a lot more subtle than that. Brian Tracy researched what small daily habits these successful entrepreneurs adopted on their journey from rags to riches.


Here's Why You Should Steal Someone Else's Leadership Style

To become the best leader you can be, you must start by being a version of the leaders you most admire.

Starting a Business

Free Event | February 9: Solopreneur Office Hours with Terry Rice

Running a one person business is challenging, but we're here to help you. Tune in as our expert, Terry Rice, answers your most pressing questions.

Business News

Mark Cuban's Grocery Store Hack Will Help You Score Cheaper Produce

The billionaire talked about his early days in Dallas when he was strapped for cash.