Angels, Equity and a Shark of One's Own
Many small-business owners dream of finding an angel investor or two who would pump cash into their business and help them expand.
In my experience, though, most of these dreams are more like delusions. Why? Most business owners don't have a realistic sense of what they'd have to give up to an angel investor. And often, once you find out what you'd be giving up by taking on an investor, you're not interested.
First up was Wild Squirrel Nut Butter, whose two perky young University of Oregon college-student owners hoped to get $50,000 for 10 percent of their business. They were followed by the band Cab20, seeking $200,000 for 20 percent of their business.
Next was the one furthest into dreamland, interchangeable-parts swimwear startup Mix Bikini, which wanted $50,000 for just 5 percent of their business (which they hastily increased -- but only up to 10 percent).
And finally, the son of Tae Bo legend Billy Blanks, dancer Billy Blanks Jr., sought $100,000 for 20 percent of his fitness-video program.
Have none of these people ever met an angel investor before? Sure, angel investors are rich. But that doesn't mean they hand out their money freely.
Related Video: A Sneak Peek at Shark Tank's Season Finale
They are taking a risk on your business with their dollars and expect a big chunk of ownership in your business in return. Usually, it's 50 percent or more. I was surprised when Shark Barbara Corcoran did a deal for $50,000 for only 40 percent of Wild Squirrel. That was an unusually low equity stake.
The thing about offering such low percentages of equity for a six-figure sum on a startup is it means you are overvaluing your company. If 20 percent of your company is worth $100,000, that means you think it's a half-million-dollar business. Angels often disagree, particularly if you've barely begun to book any sales.
Another thing: When an investor comes in, they want a piece of the whole pie. For instance, Cab20 was thinking its deal should exclude the band's copyrights, an idea the Sharks roundly rejected. Kevin O'Leary was interested for 50 percent of everything, and Cab20 passed. Sharks Mark Cuban and Daymond John offered Blanks $100,000 for half his business, a deal he initially balked at but ended up taking.
That's the hard decision entrepreneurs seeking investors usually have to make: whether to cut your business ownership in half in return for the capital you need.
Would you give 50 percent equity in your business to an angel investor? Leave a comment and tell us why -- or why not.