How Yogurt Brand Noosa Thrived By Cancelling Its Biggest Retail Deal

The brand's first big break nearly broke it. But it also taught Noosa an important lesson about growing at the right pace.
How Yogurt Brand Noosa Thrived By Cancelling Its Biggest Retail Deal
Image credit: Noosa

Franchise Your Business

Schedule a FREE one-on-one session with one of our Franchise Advisors today and we’ll help you start building your franchise organization.
Entrepreneur Staff
Editor in Chief
5 min read

Introducing our new podcast, Problem Solvers with Jason Feifer, which features business owners and CEOs who went through a crippling business problem and came out the other side happy, wealthy, and growing. Feifer, Entrepreneur's editor in chief, spotlights these stories so other business can avoid the same hardships. Listen below or click here to read more shownotes.

Koel Thomae thought retail was simple: When a major chain wants to carry your product, you say yes. So that’s what she did in 2011, when a New York City retailer courted her Colorado-­based yogurt brand, Noosa. “We felt it was a great opportunity,” she says, “and just blindly went into this without any critical eye on how complex it could be.” Never mind that Noosa, an Australian-style creamy and sweet yogurt, had been founded only a year earlier and, despite a solid start, was still a largely local brand. Or that Thomae, a former supply chain manager at a beverage company, had never launched a business before. This, she figured, was her ticket to the big time.  

Ten months later, Noosa had lost $100,000.

“That was a massive hit to both our cash flow position,” she says, “and our egos.” She had to pull out of the deal. But the experience taught her an important lesson: A company doesn’t just need growth—it needs the right growth, and it should only take opportunities it’s prepared for. To pull that off, Noosa couldn’t distribute itself willy-nilly. It would need a proactive, strategic plan.

Related: What to Do When Your Product Goes From Beloved to Hated on Amazon

The first step was to talk to other food companies about their own expansion strategies. This helped Thomae diagnose what went wrong in New York. For example, she learned that she’d found an incompatible retailer—the kind that expects by-the-book delivery processes, will reject shipments that are even a smidge late, and attracts customers that buy mostly mainstream brands. Some other retailers are more encouraging of small brands and forgiving of shipment problems, and attract customers who like trying new things. Going forward, she’d need to find partners like those.

She also learned that Noosa couldn’t simply appear on shelves and expect to sell. In-store samplings only work so much. In order to gain traction, Noosa would need to build a larger presence anywhere it went—appearing in multiple retailers, and marketing throughout the city.

Related: This Entrepreneur Learned That When You Try Making 'Something For Everyone,' You Attract Nobody

“We couldn’t afford to be everywhere at once,” Thomae says. It was crazy to even try. So instead, Noosa decided to expand regionally—moving strongly into one nearby area until it found success, and then carrying that momentum to somewhere nearby. It started at Safeway in Northern California and heavily invested in promotions with across-town sampling and guerrilla marketing teams. Then it moved outward, covering the Pacific Northwest.

In 2014, after two years of strategic expansion, Noosa hit a crossroads. It had proven the market for its yogurt and was on track to do $100 million in sales, but it was also maxing out its production facility and occasionally running out of supply. “Retail partners understandably have a short fuse with these types of growing pains,” Thomae says. So Noosa took investment from the private equity firm Advent International—helping it increase production, hire new talent, and then expand more aggressively.

Among its newly funded expansion plans: Noosa took another crack at New York. This time, it hired a boutique distributor who knew every big store and little bodega in town. “I did ride-alongs,” Thomae says. “You grow a very thick skin from that experience. They are tough!” But they were also interested.

Today Noosa is doing more than $170 million in annual sales across 25,000 retail locations nationwide—and that includes the New York City retailer she had to pull out of seven years earlier. Noosa is back. And this time, it’s ready to sell.

In this episode of Problem Solvers, we walk through what Noosa learned from its retail disaster -- and how it learned to slow down, be strategic, and plan for long-term success. Listen below or subscribe on iTunes, Google Play,or wherever you get your podcasts.

Thanks to our sponsor

Anyone who's ever had to sign and mail a paper document has wondered: There’s got to be a better way to do this. And there is! SignEasy is a easy-to-use, simple and legal way to digitally sign documents. You can sign them yourself, from anywhere and on any device, or send documents to customers, partners, or colleagues for signing, and even track the progress of documents and get notified when a document is signed. And if someone's late in signing, you can send them a reminder. With SignEasy, there's no reason to deal with documents you have to print and sign and put in a mailbox. SignEasy is faster, easier, and safer. To get started for free go to

ProsperWorks knows what everyone in sales knows: CRMs are really tedious. "Somewhere along the way," its website says, "CRM got really hard to use." And that's why ProsperWorks has built a CRM that's the opposite. By integrating with tools you’re already using and eliminating repetitive tasks with automation, ProsperWorks is beautiful, easy to use and drives productivity to help you and your team sell more, faster. Try ProsperWorks for free by using our link.

More from Entrepreneur
Entrepreneur Select: A Fund For Entrepreneurs, By Entrepreneurs

Entrepreneurs require more than just money, which is why we aim to empower you, as well as act as a catalyst for value creation.

Entrepreneur Insider members enjoy exclusive access to business resources for just $5/mo:
  • Premium articles, videos, and webinars
  • An ad-free experience
  • A weekly newsletter
  • A 1-year Entrepreneur magazine subscription delivered directly to you
Whether you want to learn something new, be more productive, or make more money, the Entrepreneur Store has something for everyone:
  • Software
  • Gadgets
  • Online Courses
  • Travel Essentials
  • Housewares
  • Fitness & Health Devices
  • And More

Latest on Entrepreneur